News

| Submit CommentSubmit Comments | View CommentsView Comments(15)
Roger Jones lost his seat to the Community Action Party
Roger Jones lost his seat to the Community Action Party

More video


advertisement

Shocks in Salford as Jones is out

Pamela Welsh
2/ 5/2008

ROGER Jones, champion of the controversial congestion charge, was one of three high profile casualties in the local elections in Salford.

Jones, the man behind the toll tax, came third in Irlam, behind Rick Houlton from the Community Action Party, who won the vote, and the Conservatives' Stephen Fitzsimmons.

Jones will now not only lose his seat on the council, but will also forfeit his position as chair of the GMPTA, the body pushing through plans for the Toll Tax.

Also defeated was the mayor of the city, Councillor Valerie Burgoyne. She lost her seat to Liberal Democrat Martin O'Neill, who will now join his father Joe on the council benches, representing Swinton South ward.

Alan Broughton lost his seat in Eccles to the Tory candidate Judith Tope. The Labour losses means the party now has 36 seats on the council, 13 for the Conservatives, and 10 for the Liberal Democrats, with one other.

Further coverage in next week's Advertiser ...

State of the parties:

Labour 36 (-6)
Conservative 13 (+3)
Lib Dem 10 (+2)
Others 1 (+1)

Barton

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Ronald Benjamin Liberal Democrats 489
  Abdul Mannan Conservative 701
  John Mullen Labour 1039
  Alan Valentine UK Independence Party 303

Boothstown and Ellenbrook

Candidate Party Votes
Conservative hold
  Andrew Cheetham Conservative 1867
  Catherine Connett Liberal Democrats 452
  Abdul Shahid Labour 437

Broughton

Candidate Party Votes
Labour and Co-operative Party hold
  Bernard Carson Liberal Democrats 472
  Jim King Labour and Co-operative Party 1185
  David Wolfson Conservative 383

Cadishead

Candidate Party Votes
Conservative gain from Labour
  Lyn Bramer-Kelly Conservative 1047
  Chris Dickenson Community Action Party 653
  Jimmy Hunt Labour 865
  Melanie Owen Liberal Democrats 130

Claremont

Candidate Party Votes
Liberal Democrats hold
  Chris Allcock Conservative 525
  Norman Owen Liberal Democrats 1277
  Edward O'Sullivan British National Party 295
  Robert Wakefield Labour and Co-operative Party 149
  Peter Wheeler Labour 737

Eccles

Candidate Party Votes
Conservative gain from Labour
  Alan Broughton Labour 1144
  Stephen Ferrer Liberal Democrats 479
  Judith Tope Conservative 1422

Irlam

Candidate Party Votes
Community Action Party gain from Labour
  Stephen Fitzsimmons Conservative 832
  Rick Houlton Community Action Party 1152
  Roger Jones Labour 650
  Mariska Jones Liberal Democrats 161

Irwell Riverside

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Stephen Coen Labour 888
  Anthony Healey British National Party 233
  David Lewis Conservative 286
  Kenneth Mckelvey Liberal Democrats 337

Kersal

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Peter Connor Labour 1385
  Harold Kershner Liberal Democrats 356
  Shneur Odze Conservative 1046

Langworthy

Candidate Party Votes
Liberal Democrats gain from Labour
  Lynn Drake Liberal Democrats 1049
  Andy Salmon Labour 878
  Helen Vernon Conservative 330

Little Hulton

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Susan Carson Liberal Democrats 270
  Vinnie Coleman British National Party 404
  Pat Ryan Labour 1021
  Elaine West Conservative 488

Ordsall

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Yan Cockayne Conservative 358
  Ray Mashiter Labour 860
  Liam Starkey Liberal Democrats 348

Pendlebury

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Peter Allcock Conservative 826
  Christine Corry Liberal Democrats 375
  Stuart Cremins Independent 117
  Wayne Taylor British National Party 352
  Barry Warner Labour 975

Swinton North

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Derek Antrobus Labour 1122
  Tamara Cooke Liberal Democrats 624
  Shirley Walsh Conservative 947

Swinton South

Candidate Party Votes
Liberal Democrats gain from Labour
  Hilary Brunyee Conservative 527
  Valerie Burgoyne Labour 642
  Dave Kelly Independent 347
  Martin O’Neill Liberal Democrats 1150

Walkden North

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Vincent Devine Labour 1033
  Thomas Fernley Liberal Democrats 395
  Eileen Macdonald Conservative 756

Walkden South

Candidate Party Votes
Conservative gain from Labour
  Tommy Cavanagh British National Party 336
  Pauline Ogden Liberal Democrats 458
  Brendan Ryan Labour 815
  Nicky Turner Conservative 1649

Weaste and Seedley

Candidate Party Votes
Liberal Democrats hold
  Heather Grant Conservative 478
  Tony Harold Labour 682
  Janice Heywood Liberal Democrats 1282

Winton

Candidate Party Votes
Labour hold
  Paul Doyle Independent 471
  Gary Green Conservative 593
  David Lancaster Labour 959
  Stephen Plaister Liberal Democrats 369
  Thomas Williams British National Party 251

Worsley

Candidate Party Votes
Conservative hold
  John Ferguson Labour 582
  Karen Garrido Conservative 2411
  Sheila Mulleady Liberal Democrats 476


| Submit CommentSubmit Comments | View CommentsView Comments(15)


Most recent 2 of 15 user comments

   No Richard I didn't miss the obvious my friend but I appreciate why you have said it. It was just so obvious I didn't bother to say it I suppose. Fortunately the people of Cadishead 'saw the light' and made the right tactical decision. That smug look on the Houltons' faces must be rapidly disappearing by now but I know the pair of them from old and the last thing either of them are interested in is the interests of the people of Irlam, Cadishead or Lowton East but only themselves and their own finacial interests. Heaven know, I could write a book on their dubious antics. Cllr Edward Houlton is already under investigation and his brother Richard may well also become embroiled in that investigation with referenece to their actions whilst 'electioneering', if that's what you could call it. The truth about the pair of them WILL come out eventually but the wheels of Government investigations against their own grind 'exceeding slow'. Nevertheless these two will get their just desserts you can rest assured and quite rightly so as there should no room in politics for peole who behave the way these two have. The people of Irlam deserve far better but they have to take the consequences of their actions and not getting to know their candidate and not voting at all, to me, are cardinal sins.
Irlam Realist, Irlam
16/05/2008 at 13:55
   I think you might be missing the obvious Irlam Realist. The Irlam electorate are not, as you suggest, "expecting big things" from Cllr. Houlton.

Most of those people who voted CAP were not voting for CAP but rather were using a CAP vote as a vote against Labour/Roger Jones. The CAP victory was down to a protest vote. I suspect it will prove to be a 'one hit wonder' in Salford because people will soon see through a party like that.

Given the national political circumstances and that Roger Jones was the public champion of the hated proposed toll tax what CAP pulled off (especially given the tactics it employed) in Irlam was really not so remarkable.

Cllr. Houlton will find himself isolated on Salford Council; he will have little or no influence over Salford policy-making; he is unlikely to be able to deliver substantial benefit to the Irlam electorate (given such wild, utopian promises); the ruling Salford Labour group will especially be out to get him and frustrate Houlton's attempts to deliver (which means Irlam will suffer as a pawn in a political game) in order to show that he can't deliver the goods. Houlton will quickly be marginalised and have no recourse other than to be a maverick shouting from the sidelines in the council chamber whilst his opportunities for making any positive contributions - if he has anything constructive to offer (and not just slagging off Labour) - to Salford politics will be slim to none.

The Irlam electorate would've done much better to register its protest against Labour/Roger Jones by voting Conservative - and it would've got much better and more credible representation on the Council had it done so - but the electorate chose the loudest in-yer-face naysayer and having made its bed it will now have to lie in it.

Mindful of the old adage 'the people get the politicians they deserve', one wonders whether some of the Irlam electorate are just stupid, quite frankly. The CAP will do nothing for Irlam because it has offered nothing that it can deliver (except the opportunity for a two fingers to Labour) and it will be quickly frozen out of the action by the other political parties and just as importantly by the various public sector organisations. It's very sad for Irlam.
Richard Carvath
12/05/2008 at 12:03
Have your say
 
Have your say Got an opinion you want to share?
Register now and have your comments heard.

Register now

MRSA
 

Should the Government provide NHS trusts with more funding to fight MRSA in hospitals?

86%
14%

Personal Finance
 

Customers with a 'good' credit profile
Company Typical APR
FirstPlus Exclusive Rate 6.6%
Moneyback Bank 7.6%
Alliance & Leicester 7.7%
Halifax (Semi-exclusive) 7.7%
Bank of Scotland (Semi-exclusive) 7.7%
Barclays 8.9%
Fixed Rate Bonds
Provider AER*
ICICI BANK
HiSAVE Fixed Rate Account
7.20%